Sales include million dollar home in Ellery
A second home in the town of Ellery has been sold this year for more than $1 million.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from May 1-8. The county does not provide transaction information, but real estate documents are available for review at the clerk’s office.
During this time period, 3445 Rt. 430, Ellery was sold for $1,150,000. It is described on line as a 3,414 square foot three bedroom, three bath single family residence on about a three-quarter acre lot.
Earlier this year a residence on Sunset Bay Drive sold for $1,585,000.
In 2025, there were five private residences in Ellery that were sold for more than $1 million, one of which was in the village of Bemus Point.
Including the sale previously mentioned, from May 1-8, there were five transactions that were $300,000 or higher.
The remaining top sales are as follows:
– 16 Peck Ave., Chautauqua Institution sold for $925,000.
– Four parcels, which total 77 acres on Walnut Road and Route 20, Sheridan, were sold for $500,000. The property on line is listed as vineyards.
– Two parcels, which total 140 acres, on Bates Road, Ellington sold for $360,000. The property on line is described as agricultural land.
– 960 Douglas Place, Hanover sold for $345,000.
Overall, from May 1-8 there were 83 transactions. The full list of sales $5,000 or higher is as follows:
MAY 1
ALW Properties of Falconer NY, LLC of Falconer sold 360 East Elmwood and 1893 East Elmwood Ext., Falconer to David Kraebel for $209,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Betty Lou DiBlasi sold 655 Creek Road, Busti to David and Valerie Thor for $100,000.
Catherine Johnner sold 26 Severn Parkway, Jamestown to Bryan Clark and Madelyn Yochim for $250,000.
John Jr. and K-Leigh Ericson sold 16 Peck Ave., Chautauqua Institution, town of Chautauqua, to Dragon Nighthawk, LLC for $925,000.
Crowell Family Holdings, LLC of South Dayton sold 1184 Cassadaga Road, Villenova to Cheryl Arndt and Brent Lee for $55,000.
J&T Cole Rentals of Sherman sold 118 Miller St., Sherman to Bishop Kopta for $95,000.
Bryce Lyon sold 11439 Hanover Road, Hanover to 4Homes, LLC of Forestville for $68,000.
Stephanie Sanchez sold 16 Main St., Forestville, town of Hanover, to Forestville Dev, LLC of Forestville for $44,000.
Cockaigne Holdings, LLC of Fredonia sold two parcels, which total 140 acres, on Bates Road, Ellington Brian and Gayle Pitts for $360,000. The property on line is described as agricultural land.
MAY 4-8
Amy Hollan sold 173 Hallock St., Jamestown to Francis Blair and Maria Portillo for $131,000.
Michael Krupinski sold 55 Kosciuszko Ave., Dunkirk to MRR Property Solutions, LLC of Dunkirk for $37,000.
Nancy Henderson sold 77 West Ave., Brocton to Cynthia Freay for $60,000.
Ericka Steiner sold four parcels on Wilson Drive and 10th Avenue, Westfield to Beachview Acres for $5,000.
Daniel Didion sold an 84-acre parcel on Doloff Road, Poland to Samuel Byler and Monroe Yoder for $110,000.
Sharon Bergstrom and Kathleen McMurray sold 149 Baker St., Jamestown to Devyn Stoll for $96,460.
David and Lisa Carlson sold 3732 Falconer Kimball Stand Road, Ellicott to Jason Swanson for $42,000.
Wendy Rosage sold 6273 Centralia Hartfield Road and a parcel on Old Route 17, Chautauqua town to Bobbi Jo Poe for $200,000.
GKHE Properties, LLC of Rocky River, Ohio to Matthew Wells for $170,000.
Arthur Jr. and Juanita Strine sold a parcel on West Side Hill Road, Ripley to Trevor and Ryleigh Enterline for $61,160.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of the Estate of Donna Pacitti sold 2793 Butts Road, Ashville, town of North Harmony, to Kevin and Cheryl Smithers for $430,000.
Terrence and Linda Toy sold 3445 Rt. 430, Ellery to Robert Glance and Melissa Pytel for $1,150,000.
Krista Campano sold 328 E. Main St., Fredonia to Timothy Joaquin Lopez-Rodriguez for $265,000.
Tyler Czekanski sold 447 Hoyt St., Dunkirk to Dorothy Hill for $70,000.
Rick Smith sold 11 N. Route 62, Ellington to William and Julie Baer for $45,000.
Margaret Topor sold 1308 Edgewater Drive, Westfield to the Hayes 2023 Family Trust for $193,000.
Lemuel and Brenda Gardner sold 960 Douglas Place, Hanover to James Franklin Elston III for $345,000.
James Rizzo Jr. sold 74 Kinney St., Brocton to Phillip Maas for $120,000.
Yu Property Management, LLC of Jamestown sold 104 Isabella Ave., Jamestown to Miriam Richardson and Dennis Baxter for $40,000.
Charles Nixon sold 133 Pulaski St., Fredonia to Patrick and Kathleen Benz for $22,500.
John Jr. and Martha Grilla sold 332 Palmer St., Jamestown to Austen Mason for $77,319.
Jeffrey and Doreen Olson sold a parcel on Johnson Road, Charlotte to Tyler Wheeler and Briana Pilewski for $30,000.
Nancy Dusckas sold 135 S. Main St., Jamestown to Leonel and Rosa Soriz for $63,000.
William and Christena Bender sold 7241 Rt. 474, Clymer to Freeman Yoder for $150,000.
Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp. sold 30 St. Hedwigs Ave., Dunkirk to Cristian Maestre for $30,000.
A referee for Cody Merril sold 90 Old Mill Road, Portland to the Secretary of Veterans Affairs for $144,221.
Erik and Kristen Bentley sold 6720 Moore Road, Chautauqua town to Jordan and Ashley Jantzi for $250,000.
Thomas Murray and Lisa Murray-Roselli sold 1175 Stewart Ave., Hanover to Paris Roselli and Lisa Murray-Roselli for $132,585.
Kathleen Andrews sold 8 Lafayette Ave., Dunkirk to Zachary Corrente and Amber Meli for $165,000.
Douglas Lockett sold 31 West Lucas Ave., Dunkirk to Carlos Montalvo for $95,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Albert VanDette Jr. sold four parcels on Walnut Road and Route 20, Sheridan to Falcone Farms, Inc. of Forestville for $500,000. The property on line is listed as vineyards and total around 77 acres.
Lucas and Alesha Trombley sold 10610 Swamp Road, Sheridan to Alysia Burgess and Anthony St. George for $260,000.



