Breaking News
Local/Region

Court system refuses to remove state Supreme Court Justice from real estate case

By JOHN WHITTAKER 11 min read

A Staten Island attorney's request to the Eighth Judicial District to remove a local attorney and judge from a property acquisition lawsuit that now involves three separate filings in state Supreme Court and, now, the Chautauqua County Land Bank, has been denied.

Michelle RE & Legacy Properties LLC has filed four lawsuits in state Supreme Court since March 2025 involving the possible sale of property at 52 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown. Michelle RE & Legacy Properties had paid a $30,000 downpayment on the property as part of an as-is sale in September 2024. The fight over a failed real estate deal now encompasses four separate lawsuits, one appeal to the Fourth Department Appellate Division, the failed request to have state Supreme Court Justice Grace Hanlon removed from the case and allegations of misconduct by attorneys representing Michelle RE & Legacy Properties, a Staten Island based company, and Chadwick and Stefanie Sunday, the Ohio residents who recently sold 52 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown, to the Chautauqua County Land Bank.

FIRST LAWSUIT

An initial lawsuit was filed in 2025 in state Supreme Court in Richmond County involving the listing of 52 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown. That first suit alleged the sale listings were fraudulent because water and sewer services weren’t connected as listed, there was not an electric water heater in the property and the garage didn’t have a new roof when the entire property was advertised as having a new roof. Attorneys from Gregg & Associates in Staten Island allege the Property Condition Disclosure Statement for 52 Lakeview Ave. was knowingly false and inaccurate, and asked the court to force Chadwick and Stefanie Sunday, who live in Ohio, to pay $53,346.53, which is the cost to connect the sewer, purchase an electric hot water heater, replace the garage roof, pay the cost of an EPA-certified risk assessment, $10,000 for lead-based paint remediation and $10,000 in additional damages.

State Supreme Court in Richmond County dismissed the complaint in September 2025 on the grounds that Richmond County had no jurisdiction hearing a breach of contract case involving a property in another county and that there had not been proper personal service of the complaint. Judge Ralph J. Porzio also declined to sign a proposed order in April 2025 that would have required Chadwick Sunday, Stefenie Plymale and Stefenie Plymale-Sunday to appear in court to explain why the court shouldn’t issue a temporary restraining order prohibiting the Sundays from selling the property, spending Michelle RE’s $30,000 downpayment earnest money and prohibiting the Sundays or their agents or representatives from being within 1,000 feet of the property.

SECOND LAWSUIT

A similar case was then filed in state Supreme Court in Chautauqua County. That case alleges the falsely advertised benefits of utilities, appliances and new roof did not exist. The lawsuit also alleges there was no disclosure of lead-based paint or lead-based paint hazards in the property despite the Sundays allegedly signing a disclosure that the seller had no knowledge of lead-based paint or lead-based paint hazards in the property. The attorneys also allege the Sundays made an inaccurate disclosure of smoke alarm installation when there was no smoke or carbon monoxide detectors in the home.

Judge Stephen Cass issued an Order to Show Cause in April 2025. Judge Stephen Cass issued an Order to Show Cause in April 2025. A hearing was scheduled for July 7, 2025, but attorneys for Michelle RE & Building Legacy LLC arrived 30 minutes after the scheduled date and time. Hanlon then dismissed the motion for civil and criminal contempt in a civil action that had been filed by the LLC.

THIRD CASE

A third case was then filed in October 2025 asking Hanlon to force the Sundays to return the $30,000 downpayment, along with pre- and post-judgement interest, until the sale of the property to Michelle & RE Legacy Building LLC was finalized. Hanlon granted an Order to Show Cause and set a hearing to be held Dec. 2, 2025, virtually since the seller and buyer of 52 Lakeview Ave. both live hours away from Jamestown. On Dec. 23, 2025, Hanlon granted a motion filed by the Sundays’ attorney, Joseph Calimeri, canceling and vacating the Notice of Pendency filed Oct. 15, 2025, by Gregg and Associates while also denying Gregg and Associates’ request for a temporary restraining order preliminary injunction and allowing the 52 Lakeview Avenue property to be sold with all net proceeds retained by Wright Calimeri PLLC until the matter is resolved by Hanlon. A Notice of Pendency (often called a lis pendens) in New York is a filing placed in public land records alerting third parties that a lawsuit affecting specific real property is pending. Governed primarily by New York CPLR Article 65, it gives constructive notice from the moment of filing so later buyers or lenders take title subject to the outcome of the case.

On Oct. 13, 2026, Hanlon ruled against a motion by Michelle & RE Legacy Building LLC to strike an answer from the Calimeri and a counterclaim while also denying the LLC’s request for attorneys fees to be paid by the Sundays.

Gregg entered into the court record a transcript of a virtual court appearance held Sept. 29 during which Michelle & RE Legacy Building LLC’s attorneys argued Calimeri had willfully held up discovery in the case in an attempt to preclude evidence from being used at an upcoming hearing and trial. Attorney Thomas Shanahan, who appeared in court on behalf of Gregg, said paper discovery and depositions had not been completed according to court-ordered timetables.

“There’s concessions by Mr. Calimeri that he has not complied with his discovery obligations, but they’re minimized and marginalized,” Shanahan said. “But these are important because there’s been a complete failure on every level to comply with this court order. And so, again, there’s an admission in his opposition if it’s considered, that in fact, he did fail to comply with these court orders. We believe the proper remedy – because it’s not just a one off, it’s a pattern – is to strike the answer or at the very least preclude evidence that hasn’t been produced but it’s been timely requested. And so, again, to the extent this is considered, I do think there are questions about why there’s been such deviation from the court order, and that your Honor can question Mr. Calimeri about that.”

Calimeri, according to the transcript, said there was a substantial amount of litigation and legal practice that had gone on between the time the initial complaint was filed, when the amended complaint was filed and then the subsequent answer and counterclaim, a pre-pleading motion and then arguments in front of the Fourth Department Appellate Division. The answer and counterclaim was filed three days after argument before the Appellate Division, which Calimeri was necessary because the arguments he would make were different depending on the appeals court ruling. The four-day delay in providing discovery materials was in part due to the fact there were two prior attorneys on the case – one assigned by the public defender’s office and another who worked on the underlying real estate case. Records had to be secured from each of the other attorneys before Calimeri could produce a response.

“Quite honestly, your honor, I sat on that for a long time because of the 22 demands of my client, 18 were both either unethical or just completely inappropriate,” Calimeri said. “As articulated to and alluded to in my motion practice, they’re seeking bank account information, employer information. They asked as far as they wanted privileged material and communications with (another attorney). And quite candidly, given the nature in which the plaintiff’s counsel has handled this case, I was determining whether or not there would be some course of action to strike those interrogatories. I didn’t do that. But that was the real main cause for delay on account of the fact that it was just a wholly inappropriate document.”

Hanlon agreed with Calimeri, which helped prompt portions of the fourth lawsuit that sought to have both Hanlon and Calimeri removed from the proceedings.

“I don’t find that a four-day delay, Mr. Shanahan, is prejudicial or contemptuous,” Hanlon said. “The practice of law in Chautauqua County is vastly different from the practice of law in Manhattan. We don’t have enough lawyers. People are overrun with work. So delays are not willful here, they’re just the practice of law and litigation in that substantive way. I also find that the fact that Mr. Calimeri’s clients live in Ohio makes things more difficult. So that is my decision, Mr. Shanahan.”

FOURTH CASE

While the third case is winding its way through the state Supreme Court, a fourth case has been filed. This case involves the Chautauqua County Land Bank, its board members and its executive director, Gina Paradis. While the state Supreme Court is hearing the initial case, 52 Lakeview Ave. has been sold to the Chautauqua County Land Bank. Michelle & RE Legacy Building LLC is asking the Eighth Judicial District for a temporary restraining order preventing the property from being torn down or from being entered as well as to keep the $30,000 currently being held in escrow from being moved until the court cases come to a conclusion.

The LLC's attorneys also asked the Eighth Judicial District to assign a new judge to both the case filed this week and the third case filed in 2025.

Ronald A. Gregg of Gregg and Associates argues that judicial reassignment is needed because of a severe conflict of interest that involves the earlier case. Gregg said the order to cancel the Notice of Pendency allowed the property to be sold to the Land Bank while using a falsified and stale Property Disclosure Statement and fraudulent Lead-Based Pain Disclosure. Gregg is also asking the court to require the Sundays to use a different attorney, with this week’s filing alleging attorney deceit that includes a willful default and non-appearance at a court-sanctioned discovery inspection in April 2026 and lack of candor by allegedly hiding the physical liquidation of the lawsuit’s subject matter from Michelle RE & Legacy Building LLC.

“Because the allegations of attorney deceit and the willful suppression of the physical sale occurred directly during the active lifespan of the underlying proceeding, Justice Hanlon has inherently been placed in an untenable supervisory position,” Gregg argued in a court filing this week. “Forcing the presiding justice to adjudicate a highly contentious disqualification motion regarding a rogue advocate who has spent the last year practicing before her part creates immense institutional friction and risks the appearance of a conflict. To preserve absolute judicial impartiality and shield the record from any perception of part-protective bias, an independent, separate Supreme Court Justice from outside the Chautauqua structure must be assigned to hear and rule upon the Motion to Disqualify, ensuring an entirely neutral arbiter handles the fallout of this professional misconduct across both indexes.”

On Wednesday, the Eighth Judicial District ruled against the motion to remove Hanlon.

“Even assuming, arguendo, that Justice Martoche is empowered to effectuate a transfer or transfers under these circumstances, your letter does not provide grounds for such action or actions,” attorney Michael Patrick wrote on behalf of the judicial district. “In addition to incorporating multiple ‘ghost’ citations; your correspondence is both premised upon conjecture (including, for example, the supposition that your allegation of violation of Judiciary Law Section 487 has merit) and otherwise misdirected (inasmuch as what effectively are your requests for approval and disqualification should be directed to Justice Hanlon).”

For his part, Calimeri expressed issues both in open court in September and in correspondence with the court about the way Gregg & Associates has handled its end of the litigation. That includes saying in court documents that Gregg & Associates had attempted multiple times to reach Calimeri by phone or email with no response – an allegation Calimeri says phone logs prove is false.

"Lastly, in general, I find it offensive and hypocritical of the plaintiff to accuse our office of acting in bad faith,” Calimeri wrote in a memorandum filed in September. “It was this plaintiff that attempted to seek a default judgment through the Chautauqua County Clerk on its initial complaint after the court denied its application. Also, the plaintiff admitted that the reason why it withdrew its initial complaint against the defendant was because they attempted to forum shop and file for a default judgment in a different county. I respectfully request that the court see through this vicious and patently offensive attack on your affiant’s character and dismiss the plaintiff’s requests in its entirety.”

Starting at /week.