Legislature rejects benefit change for managers
Trending
MAYVILLE - After a couple of months of indecision, county lawmakers have rejected a proposal to have managers get the same retirement insurance benefits as union employees.
Back in September, the Chautauqua County Legislature looked at modifying a local law that would permit a retiring manager to "receive paid health insurance coverage after retirement at the rate which matches that of the highest service-related calculation afforded within any county union collective bargaining unit agreement."
At both the September and October legislature meetings, county supervisors spoke out, saying that there have been times when union employees were declining promotions simply because the union benefits were better than what they would get as a supervisor. Others said that managers had left their supervisory role to rejoin the union later in their careers, simply because of the benefits the union members get in retirement.
In both September and October, the legislature sent the change to the local law back to committee for further discussion.
During Wednesday night's county legislature meeting, Legislator Tom Nelson, D-Jamestown, said he supported the change. "First, I think it’s important to provide competitive benefits to attract and retain qualified management employees. Second, I believe we should recognize the years of service our management employees have given to the county. But mostly I support this because it protects benefits earned in union positions. Many of our county employees spent years serving the county beginning in union positions before moving into management," he said.
But Legislator Fred Johnson, R-Westfield, disagreed. "What Legislator Nelson was talking about is the heart of a good comp and benefits policy and strategy. This is not the way to go about it. ... If we have a compensation issue at any part of our employees relative to the marketplace, then let’s deal with it in a professional manner. But cherry-picking a particular benefit and then just running it across the management group is not a way to go about this," he said.
The local law as written did not specify what the potential cost would be. That bothered Legislator Chuck Nazzaro, D-Jamestown, who was sworn into office in October. "I’ve not heard the cost to the county," he said.
During various committee meetings, there had been talk about what the potential costs would be, but that was never made clear.
During the October Audit and Control Committee meeting, Johnson thought the cost would be $8 million, but County Finance Director Kitty Lyons said, "I'm not sure an actuary would calculate it at that."
Lyons did confirm that over time, this proposed change would be an increase of expenses.
The vagueness of the cost was an issue for Legislator Lisa Vanstrom, R-West Ellicott. "We didn’t have solid numbers and this as it was presented will go on in perpetuity, which means this bill doesn’t go away," she said.
The resolution failed with six legislators voting in favor and 10 voting against it, with both sides having a mix of Republicans and Democrats.
Voting in favor were Legislators Jamie Gustafson, R-Lakewood; Tom Harmon, R-Silver Creek; Nelson; Dan Pavlock, R-Ellington; Bob Scudder, R-Fredonia; and Chairman Pierre Chagnon, R-Ellery.
Voting no were Legislators Dalton Anthony, R-Frewsburg; Bob Bankoski, D-Dunkirk; Marcus Buchanan, D-Dunkirk; Jason Merritt, R-Sheridan; Travis Heiser, R-Clymer; Johnson; Nazzaro; John Penhollow, R-Stockton; Vanstrom; and Legislator Bob Whitney, D-Jamestown.
Legislators Fred Larson, D-Jamestown; Sandra Lewis, D-Fredonia; and Marty Proctor, R-Mina, were absent.