Local/Region

Sales include bowling alley, former church

A north county bowling establishment has a new owner.

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from Aug. 27-31. The county does not provide transaction information, but real estate documents are available for review at the clerk's office.

During this time period, Hanover Lanes, LLC sold 1539 Rt. 5, Hanover to Michael Scritchfield for $100,000.

The business is going by Hanover Pub and Alleys on Facebook. It had a soft grant opening in September, noting they were still doing remodeling and construction. A new menu was announced in October.

Also during this time period, Barber Equipment Leasing, LLC sold 60 Franklin St., Westfield to Bass Equity Holdings, LLC for $155,000. At one point this was the location of Green Star Pallet & Recycling, however their website, phone number and email address are no longer in operation.

In a separate sale, Big Dawg Properties of WNY, LLC purchased 1739 Lindquist Dr., Poland for $320,000. This was the location of I-86 Truck Repair & Auto Service, which closed earlier this year. In June, RSGA - Repair Shop & Gasoline Association of NY posted on Facebook that the owner of I-86 Truck Repair & Auto Service had retired, sold the shop and was auctioning off the contents. "We wish I-86 Truck Repair & Auto Service the best of luck," they wrote.

Separately, the Diocese of Buffalo and Our Lady of the Snows Roman Catholic Church Society of Panama NY sold 36 E. Main St., Panama to Carrie and David Munsee. The Diocese portion of the sale was for $18,333, while the Our Lady of the Snows portion of the sale was for $119,167. The Our Lady of the Snows Catholic Church permanently closed in 2025 as part of the Diocese of Buffalo’s "Road to Renewal" re-organization plan.

Also during this time, Bone Creek, LLC sold 114 East Main St., Sherman to Williams Restoration and Construction, LLC for $125,000. According to the county GIS page, this is labeled as a lumber yard mill. Specialty Millworks, which specialized in crafting custom wood products, operated out of this address.

Including the sale previously mentioned, from Aug. 27-31, there were nine sales that were $300,000 or higher. The remaining top sales are as follows:

- 4948 E. Shorewood Drive, Dunkirk town sold for $749,900.

- 89 Bird and Tree Road, Mayville sold for $725,000.

- 2546 Shadyside Rd., Mina sold for $670,000.

- 2440B Shadyside Rd., Mina sold for $585,700.

- 6029 Gull Rd., Chautauqua town sold for $530,000.

- 36 Park Ave., Cassadaga sold for $420,000.

- 2398 Lakeside Drive, Busti sold for $360,000.

- 5082 Berry Road, Pomfret sold for $340,000.

- 3009 Rt. 430, Ellery sold for $300,000.

Overall, from Aug. 27-31 there were 68 transactions. The full list of sales $5,000 or higher is as follows:

AUG. 27-28

Carla and Daryl Kluczynski sold 89 Bird and Tree Road, Mayville to the Richard L. Bopp Revocable Trust for $725,000.

Christopher and Jane Simcik sold 4948 E. Shorewood Drive, Dunkirk town to Michael Sorek and Ann Giannelli for $749,900.

Arthur and Concetta Kennedy sold 2365 Carlson Rd., Kiantone to Kathleen Calimeri for $192,000.

Terry Myers sold 1871 Delaware Ave., Falconer to Kadan Myers for $30,000.

Jason Dorman sold 16 Gerald Ave., Lakewood to Madison Dorman for $35,000.

Nelda Gostomski sold 255 Rt. 39, Hanover to Scott and Tracy Gostomski for $200,000.

Julia Bozza sold 126 Cornish St., Sherman to Kenneth Smith for $100,000.

Veronica Diaz sold 329 E. Main St., Westfield to Darren Brennan for $47,500.

Brett and Cynthia Ligo sold 2440B Shadyside Rd., Mina to Eric and Brooke Gradert for $585,700.

K Smith Properties, LLC of Ashville sold 212 Broadhead Ave., Jamestown to Jennifer and Scott Smith for $55,000.

The Cusimano Family Irrevocable Asset Protection Trust sold 163 Hunt Rd., Ellicott to Paul Taber for $235,000.

Richard Helt and Sandra Maitland sold 3009 Rt. 430, Ellery to Brennan and Ellen Webb for $300,000.

The executrix of the Estate of the Last Will and Testament of Norma F. Michaloski sold 6449 Lawson Rd., Chautauqua town to Nicholas Perison for $47,000.

Joanne Sigular sold 69 Stewart Ave., Jamestown to Thomas Bailey Jr. for $40,000.

502 Foote, LLC sold 504 Foote Ave., Jamestown to Taymont Rentals, LLC of Jamestown for $27,500.

Brian Seibert sold 36 Park Ave., Cassadaga to Jennifer Dee Paco for $420,000.

Barber Equipment Leasing, LLC of Westfield sold 60 Franklin St., Westfield to Bass Equity Holdings, LLC of Westfield for $155,000.

The administrator of the Last Will and Testament of Nancy Paterniti sold 59 E. Front St., Dunkirk to Vernon Pchelka for $30,000.

Nathan Whitford sold 1739 Lindquist Dr., Poland to Big Dawg Properties of WNY, LLC of Olean for $320,000.

Hanover Lanes, LLC of Silver Creek sold 1539 Rt. 5, Hanover to Michael Scritchfield for $100,000.

The Diocese of Buffalo, NY sold 36 East Main St., Panama to Carrie and David Munsee for $18,333.

Our Lady of the Snows Roman Catholic Church Society of Panama NY of Jamestown sold part of 36 East Main St., Panama to Carrie and David Munsee for $119,167.

A referee for Richard Prince sold 189 E. Second St., Dunkirk to Paul Milazzo for $69,000.

Brian and Lori Peterson sold 2398 Lakeside Drive, Busti to Connie Depowski for $360,000.

Mark and Mary Matteson sold 24 Lowell Place, Fredonia to Paul Corrigan and Ruth Antosh for $172,500.

Charles Gilbert Jr. sold 18 E. Ave., Sinclairville to Olivia Walker for $52,500.

The Michael and Antoinette Naeser Revocable Living Trust sold two parcels on North Gale Street, Westfield to Knight Family, LLC of Ripley for $52,000.

Scott Richir sold 5082 Berry Road, Pomfret to Brian Seibert for $340,000.

Michael and Cynthia Evancho sold 12210 Hanford Rd., Hanover to Alex and Mary Fenske for $216,000.

The Winston K. Guy Revocable Living Trust sold 6029 Gull Rd., Chautauqua town to the Randall and Janis Sumner Family Trust for $530,000.

Donald and Lynn Levengood sold 2546 Shadyside Rd., Mina to Spartan Real Estate, LLC of Rocky River, Ohio for $670,000.

The executors of the Last Will and Testament of John P. Woloszyn sold 55 Ounce St. and Rabbit Street, Dunkirk to David Folland, Susan Grosse and Diana Folland for $299,900.

Brennan Webb and Ellen Lockwood Webb sold 124 Hotchkiss St., Jamestown to Richard Helt for $167,500.

MK River Holdings, LLC of Kennedy sold 50 Babcock St., Ellicott to Kayelynn Graham and Charles Monroe for $208,600.

AUG. 31

Jomarie Nagel sold 131 Elam Ave., Jamestown to Nathalia Santiago Gonzalez for $87,000.

Bone Creek, LLC of Mayville sold 114 East Main Street, Sherman to Williams Restoration and Construction, LLC of Randolph for $125,000.

Bee Lumber Company, LLC of Jamestown sold 5302 North Hill Rd., Ellington to Johnny and Anna Shetler for $30,000.

Justin Adleff and Judith Eugenio-Adleff sold 2382 Sunnyside Rd., Mina to Leslie Vincent and J. Daniel Wintermantel for $290,000.

John and Lorinda Johnson sold 178 Front St., Busti to Oliver Dow for $280,000.