Transactions include former fire station, Ellicott business
A former Fredonia fire station that houses multiple businesses has a new owner.
The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from April 11-20.
During that time period, Church Street Holdings, LLC of Fredonia sold 33 Church St. to 33 Church St. LLC of Jamestown for $825,000. This is known as the Fenner Fire Station, where the fire department used to be located. The building currently houses the restaurant Dupers, Express Employment Professionals, HBKS Wealth Advisors, and Salon Belle Vie, a full service hair salon.
In the town of Ellicott, there were three business sales.
Cattaraugus County Bank sold 870 Fairmount Ave., Ellicott to Mitchener Realty, LLC of Falconer for $700,000. This was CCB’s former location. The bank moved to 284 E. Fairmount Ave. Work is being done on the property. According to Ellicott officials, Dr. James Mitchener, DDS is opening another location of Southern Tier Dentistry. He has a location in Falconer and is in the process of opening another location in Lakewood.
600 Fairmount Ave. was sold to 225 Enterprises, LLC of Jamestown for $497,000. This is the former Hollyloft Ski and Bike business. Owners Les and Cheryl Johnson announced in The Post-Journal that they were closing Dec. 24, 2020 after 42 years in business. No announcement has been made for what the location will be used for in the future.
Gap Enterprises of WNY LLC of Jamestown sold 679 and 663 Fairmount Ave. to Thomas Turner for $150,000. This is the former location of The Art of Flavors, a Mexican Restaurant. On Facebook, the restaurant owners posted a gofundme link in July saying that one of the managers was dealing with stomach cancer. Gap Enterprises of WNY LLC has purchased and sold other property in the past.
In Westfield, two downtown locations were sold.
Ogden Newspapers of New York, Inc. sold 39-41 East Main St., Westfield to John and Suzanne Mckay for $125,000. This is the former location of The Westfield Republican. In its place is a new antique business called Suzanne’s at Overton.
Michelle Jungquist and Billy Miller sold 19 N. Portage St., Westfield to RC Design and Development, LLC of Mayville for $165,000. This is the previous location of The Living Room Wine and Cheese Bar.
In Jamestown, 522 E. Second St. was sold to Reliance Enterprises VI, Inc. of Jamestown for $110,000. This was the location of A Taste From Above. Signs in the windows show it sold pizza, wings, subs and strombolis.
Also, S and P Johnson, LLC of Ashville sold 2 E. Main St., Panama to Hammond Family, LLC of Sherman for $60,000. This is the location of Crouch’s Garage. In April, the owners announced the sale of the business on Facebook, saying the business was sold after 40 years.
From April 11-20, there were seven sales that were $250,000 or higher. The remaining four sales were as follows:
¯ 129 Sea Lion Drive, Mayville sold for $980,000.
¯ 4470 Fairmount Ave., Busti sold for $309,000.
¯ 1079 Forest Ave. Ext., Busti sold for $300,000.
¯ 9125 Chautauqua Road, Pomfret, sold for $264,900.
The full list of transaction from April 11-20 are as follows:
Louis Fernandez sold 122 S. Roberts Road, Dunkirk to EZ Property of WNY, LLC of Stockton for $30,000.
Robert Cole Jr. sold 566 Rt. 394, Poland, to Brian Hinman for $27,000.
Dianna and Thomas Buttafarro sold 202 Huxley St., Ellicott to Stacy Felton for $45,000.
Leland Davis and Richard Kirkman sold 702 Lakeview Ave., Jamestown to Shane Moulder and Alexis Monroe for $150,000.
Signs in the windows show it sold pizza, wings, subs and strombolis., Dunkirk to Gloria Martinez for $35,000.
Shannon Snow sold 43 Lee Ave., Jamestown to Jessica Riquer for $62,000.
Jay Besemer sold 10056 Patterson Lane, Portland to Colleen Fox for $107,320.
Jane Beckerink sold 7809 Nazareth Road, Clymer to Sherry Jengo for $75,000.
The administrator of the Estate of Susan M. Chompalov sold 8716 Ravlin Hill Road, Clymer to Noah and Ruth Shetler for $77,000.
Wallace and Sarah Weaver sold property on Route 474, Clymer to Mahlon and Barbara Miller for $10,000.
Cattaraugus County Bank sold 870 Fairmount Ave., Ellicott to Mitchener Realty, LLC of Falconer for $700,000.
Mahendra Basdeo sold 113 Willard St., Jamestown to MK River Holdings, LLC of Kennedy for $100.
Aleena Baksh sold 215-217 Winsor St., Jamestown to MK River Holdings, LLC of Kennedy for $100.
Charles Lillie sold 8783 Pecor St., Portland to Theresa Bigelow for $61,900.
Barbara McArthur sold 129 Bowen St., Jamestown to Camille Steele for $74,200.
Arlie and Shelly Quackenbush sold 9 Squires Ave., Lakewood to Stacey Chase for $61,500.
Kerry Smith sold 3523 Rt. 20, Sheridan to Sarah Titus and Michael Waddington for $155,000.
Dennis and Cherie Vittum sold 619 Deer St., Dunkirk to Carlos Manuel Brunet for $75,000.
James Castagnino sold 4470 Fairmount Ave., Busti to David and Judith Redmond for $309,000.
Ogden Newspapers of New York, Inc. of Wheeling, West Virginia sold 39-41 East Main St., Westfield to John and Suzanne Mckay for $125,000.
Jamie Berg and Sally Berg sold 1079 Forest Ave. Ext., Busti to Thomas and Carol Post for $300,000.
Janelle Cole sold 41-43 Clinton St., Westfield to American Properties of Chautauqua County, LLC of Westfield f or $12,000.
Victoria Bertrand sold Home No. 8034 Northgate II Condominium to Charles and Linda Gorski for $215,000.
Andrew Proctor sold 20 Pennsylvania Ave., Jamestown to Garrett and Alexandra Turner for $75,500.
Ross Cali sold property on Vinnie St., Jamestown to Michael Morgan for $14,000.
David Delorenzo sold property on Hunt Road, Busti to Scott and Merry Schang for $17,000.
Gap Enterprises of WNY LLC of Jamestown sold 679 and 663 Fairmount Ave., Ellicott to Thomas Turner for $150,000.
Yu Property Management LLC of Jamestown to 27 Kingsbury St., Jamestown to Alfredo and Marcelina Cortez for $25,000.
Thomas Summerville sold 45 Morris St., Mayville to Zachary and Mackenzie Heilman for $90,000.
Jodie Barresi sold property on Villa Drive, Westfield to Kathryn Bronstein for $22,750.
Leslie and Cheryl Johnson sold 600 Fairmount Ave., Ellicott to 225 Enterprises, LLC of Jamestown for $497,000.
Angelique Lipari sold 22 N. Main St., Panama to Patrick Bouge for $130,000.
Derek Amell sold 129 Sea Lion Drive, Mayville to Jeanette Weitzel, Carol Soos and Lynnette Stuart for $980,000.
A referee for Andrew Lindberg sold 333 East Virginia Blvd., Jamestown to Daniel Scapelitte for $68,000.
Michael Salamone Jr. sold property on Chautauqua Stedman Road, Chautauqua town to Timothy and Kathleen Rice for $2,500.
Gioachino Giovanni Donisi sold 19 Locust St., Jamestown to Mark Avner for $79,000.
Beulah Williams sold 79 Highland Ave., Brocton to Edward and Natalie Bellando for $48,000.
Michael Kubera sold 3325 Smith Road, Charlotte to Jasoda Singh for $210,000.
Bradley Perkins sold 121 Jefferson St., Westfield to Shawna McCallum for $128,000.
Antoine and Lewis Aronson sold 3774 Westman Road, Ellery to Bridget Miller and Dylan Mitchell for $157,500.
Christina Bair sold 522 E. Second St., Jamestown to Reliance Enterprises VI, Inc. of Jamestown for $110,000.
Brian Erickson sold 6059 Rt. 474 to Kevin Erickson and Stefanie Shay for $32,900.
Christina and Melvin Santiago sold 324 Franklin Ave., Dunkirk to Lori Pellegriti and Marc Bellis for $115,000.
Charles and Jessica Riquer sold 214 Stowe St., Jamestown to Dmitri Alexeev for $8,000.
Robert J. McGuire LLC of Hamburg sold 108 S. Martin St., Dunkirk to Justin and Nayely Porter for $40,000.
Duane and Brenda Fuller sold property on Button Valley Road, Harmony to Garrett Patrick Cole Fransen and Maci Ann Johnson for $45,000.
Nichole Krupinski sold 288 Woodchuck Hill Road, Frewsburg, town of Carroll, to Timothy and Susan Allen for $230,000.
Dillon Jordan sold 1 Oliver Place, Silver Creek to Samantha Kaniewski for $150,000.
Michelle Jungquist and Billy Miller sold 19 N. Portage St., Westfield to RC Design and Development, LLC of Mayville for $165,000.
Brandon Gilliland sold 57 Cottage St., Fredonia to Scott and Shelly Freyn for $139,250.
Kenneth and Lynn Rees sold 9125 Chautauqua Road, Pomfret, to Maya Hopkins and John Kralik for $264,900.
Mervin and Betsy Byler sold 8389 E. Main St., Clymer to Willis and Paul Miller for $215,000.
Sharon Naeher sold 902 Edgewater Drive, Westfield to Lisa Nathanson and Janet Woods for $189,000.
A referee for Roberta Pratt sold 163 East Terrace, Busti to U.S. Bank National Association for $99,663.
Caitlin Smith sold 89 Tower St., Jamestown to Brianna Haskins for $18,000.
Justin Miller sold 9075 Round Top Road, Villenova to Donald Bernard Balzer for $40,000.
Darcy Lawson sold 6819 Rt. 60, Charlotte to Todd Mekus for $37,500.
Richard G. Newell sold 152 Lakeview Ave., Mayville to Richard and Sandra Newell for $71,500.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Pauline Hartzell sold 133 Migley St., Jamestown to Steven and Rhonda Ryberg for $107,500.
Lisa Borrello sold 3735 Rt. 5, Sheridan to Nelson Smoczynski for $8,000.
Paulette Brigiotta sold property on Laura Avenue, Ellicott to Liberator, LLC of Medina, Ohio for $10,000.
Chautauqua County Land Bank Corp. sold 12 Fairfield Ave., Jamestown to JTNY Properties, LLC of Jamestown for $15,000.
Gerardi Properties Inc. of Center Valley, Pa. sold 63 Front St., Dunkirk to Moises S. Ane Lebron and Elizabeth Garcia Romero for $80,000.
Church Street Holdings, LLC of Fredonia sold 33 Church St., Fredonia to 33 Church St. LLC of Jamestown for $825,000.
Martin Fisher sold 35 Maple Ave., Ripley to Alvaro Gil-Mendez for $5,000.
Randall and Amy Josephson sold 5653 Button Valley Road, Ashville, town of Harmony, to Kimberly Chelton for $140,000.
Christopher Barmore sold 2367 Fisher Hill, Chautauqua town to Trent Howard for $6,000.
David Jr. and Ruth Burkholder sold 7824 Freeman Road, Sherman to Norman and Miriam Detweiler for $150,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Deborah McCown sold 78 West Lucas Ave., Dunkirk to Paul Majecki for $115,000.
The Bank of New York Mellon sold 519 Forest Ave., Jamestown to CMG Development, LLC of Jamestown for $36,900.
Edward and Carol Smith sold 4193 Bruyer Road, Stockton to Jeffrey and Jessika Lopez for $169,900.
Florence Turner sold 180 E. Main St., Sherman to David Hinman for $162,000.
Sarah Cybart sold 149 Eagle St., Fredonia to Tracy Jennison-Cotter for $53,000.
A referee for Cargill Inc., Farmers Mill Inc., Agway Inc. and the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance sold six parcels in Sherman on Kendrick Street and Sherman-Stedman Road to TRS Transit, LLC of Carlton, Pa. for $165,000.
Ralph Reed sold property on Tenth Avenue, Westfield to Gerhardt Yaskow for $10,000.
Walter Troyer sold 1665 Bush Road, French Creek to Jacob Wengerd for $130,000.
Jennifer Fendinger, Brett Erikson and James Kelemen sold 416 Woodrow Ave., Dunkirk to Joanna Kirisits for $111,000.
The executor of the Last Will and Testament of James Noto sold 55 Tenney St., Dunkirk to Kevin and Robin Jasinski for $26,000.
Julie Williams, Jodie Bollman and Randall Odebralski sold 115 S. Martin St., Dunkirk to Amy Estep for $119,200.