×

Sales include closed golf course, $1.85M Ellery residence

OBSERVER Photo by Gregory Bacon The former Chautauqua Point Golf Course has been sold for $2.2 million, more than $1 million more for what it was sold for in 2022.

A closed golf course in the town of Chautauqua has been resold for more than double its last sale price a year ago.

The Post-Journal and OBSERVER have been analyzing real estate sales in Chautauqua County and recently looked at the transactions from July 21-31.

During this time period, Chautauqua Lake Development LLC of Springville sold 5621, 5687, 5710 East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to 1200 Group, LLC of Buffalo for $2.2 million. That is the address of Chautauqua Point Golf Course, which has been closed for the last two seasons.

In February, 2022 Camelot Golf, Inc. of Mayville sold the former golf course to Chautauqua Lake Development, LLC for $1,010,000.

The new owner has purchased other nearby properties as well. During this time period, the James K. Webb Living Trust sold property on East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to 1200 Group LLC of Buffalo for $200,000.

Also, Webb’s Harbor Restaurant and Bowling Lanes, Inc. sold 5695 East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to 1200 Group LLC of Buffalo for $200,000.

The golf course remains closed and no new development has occurred on the property.

There were other commercial sales as well.

102 East Main St., Falconer to Mission Hearing, LLC of Jamestown for $145,000. There are signs on the building for The Hearing Place and other signs that say “coming soon.”

279 Lake Shore Drive West, Dunkirk was sold to Nas Capital Development, LLC of Dunkirk for $179,000.

Chautauqua Inns, LTD of Mayville sold property on Jefferson and North Portage streets, Westfield to Mazza Chautauqua Cellars, LLC of North East, Pa. for $90,000. An email sent to the company was not returned.

There was a private residence sale that topped $1 million. The property at 4365 Lakeside Drive, Ellery sold for $1,850,000. Realtor.com describes it as a 4-bedroom, 3,444 square foot home on a 0.83 acre lot.

From July 21-31, including the sales previously mentioned, there were 11 sales that were $250,000 or higher. The other top sales were as follows:

– 4406 W. Lake Road #28, Chautauqua town sold for $355,000.

– 7086 Nelson Road, Charlotte sold for $335,000.

– 13 Merz Ave., Bemus Point sold for $327,900.

– 4 Dana Place, Silver Creek sold for $290,000.

– Condominium Unit No. G-9, Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua town sold for $285,000.

– 3305 New Road, Sheridan sold for $284,900.

– 5337 Ply Hill Road, North Harmony sold for $275,000.

– 5078 Spooner Road, Harmony sold for $271,000.

– 2258 Shadyside Road, Mina sold for $270,000.

Below are the full list of sales from July 21-31 that were higher than $1.

JULY 21

Laura Vincent sold 4004 Lawson Road, Busti, to Kayla Abbey for $105,000.

Stefan Balint sold 62 W. Doughty St., Dunkirk to Tonya Flickinger for $76,000.

Michael Catalano sold 32 Franklin St., Westfield to Jeffrey and Emmily Nelson for $165,000.

The James K. Webb Living Trust sold property on East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to 1200 Group LLC of Buffalo for $200,000.

Webbs Harbor Restaurant and Bowling Lanes, Inc. sold 5695 East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to 1200 Group LLC of Buffalo for $200,000.

Chautauqua Lake Development LLC of Springville sold 5621, 5687, 5710 East Lake Road, Chautauqua town to 1200 Group, LLC of Buffalo for $2.2 million.

Jesse and Abbe Nameche sold 28-30 Waugh Ave., Chautauqua Institution, Chautauqua town to Barbara Bauers for $200,000.

Ari Klein and Alexis Wolin sold Condominium Unit No. G-9, Chautauqua Lake Estates, Chautauqua town to Team Foreman LLC of Nazareth, Pa. for $285,000.

JULY 24-28

MZM Properties Inc. of Brocton sold 8671 First St., Portland to Kendra Anna and Alexander Skibiak for $116,600.

Levant and Dawn Carrick sold 1965 Rt. 5, Sheridan to Suzanne Accordino for $70,000.

Randall and Margaret Jolles sold 4 Dana Place, Silver Creek to Michael and Brooke Howie for $290,000.

Carlos Manuel Brunet sold 23 Wright Park Drive, Dunkirk to Michael and Linda Spino for $135,000.

Jack and Roberta Thompson sold 47 Royal Ave., Jamestown to Rose Coon for $130,000.

Joshua and Macy Warren sold 3305 New Road, Sheridan to Gerald Mekus for $284,900.

Dave and Monica Williams sold 312 Bucknor St, Dunkirk to Javier Diaz for $143,000.

Joseph Proper sold property on Orr Street Extension, Busti to Joseph and Alyvia Town for $12,400.

Marc Egleston and Mario Avarello sold property on Boutwell Hill and Housington Road, Cherry Creek for $38,000.

Beth Naetzker-McKean, Jan Naetzer and Margaret Mary Vdulich sold 5078 Spooner Road, Harmony to Kris Meekins for $271,000.

Ronald and Terri Linamen sold 2011 Willard St., Ext. (vacant) to Joseph and Brooke Cusimano for $41,000.

Clarissa Harris sold 358 Temple St., Fredonia to Tory and Faith Grupa for $185,000.

The Chautauqua County Land Bank Corporation sold 65 E. Sixth St., Dunkirk to Chaya Silver for $1,500.

The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Marcel Demonte sold 7550 East Main Road, Westfield to Ronald Gustive Kirik for $138,000.

Jonathan Bradley sold 74 N. Martin St., Dunkirk to Daniel and Amy Cassidy for $95,000.

Maurice Paterniti sold 811 E. Second St., Jamestown to MK River Holdings, LLC of Kennedy for $3,500.

Leanne Diaz sold 5139 Johnson Road, Ripley to Keith Mitchell for $80,000.

Apryl Troutman sold 328 Hall Ave., Jamestown to Sean McGee for $132,500.

The administrator of the Estate of James Scott sold 26 Utica St., Jamestown to Md Soloman Hossain for $10,500.

Sherril Rater sold 2258 Shadyside Road, Mina to Joe Hall Rentals, LLC of Monaca, Pa. for $270,000.

Connie Pitts sold 217 Newton Ave., Jamestown to Judith Anderson for $98,217.

Suzanne Murphy sold 4406 W. Lake Road #28, Chautauqua town to Daniel and Ann Dimicco for $355,000.

Timothy and Kerri Smart sold 820 Prendergast Ave., Jamestown to Mia Mabel Beatriz Arleo Gil and Paulino Dario Luis Arleo Gil for $37,000.

Raul Belardo-Sanchez sold 204 Townsend St., Dunkirk to Carlos Brunet for $80,000.

Cabhi Land Company, LLC of Clymer sold 9252 Rt. 474, French Creek to Justin and Claire White for $190,000.

The executor for the Estate of Jacqueline Wisniewski sold property on Lewis Road, Charlotte to Peter Pascatore for $67,500.

Kathleen Reynolds sold 95 East Green St., Dunkirk to Jeffrey Cook for $54,000.

The Brenda D. Whalen Asset Protection Trust sold 3200 Dutch Hollow Road, Ellery to Four T Development, Inc. of Allegany for $200,000.

Mitchell Magierski sold 2645 Rt. 20, Sheridan to Zachary and Kaitlynd Cash for $175,000.

A referee for Mary Schiller sold 147 West Sixth St., Dunkirk to WNY Partner Holdings, Inc. of Buffalo for $60,575.

Lisa Holbrook and Amanda Janisch sold 59 East Evans St., Mayville to Amanda and Michael Janisch for $116,000.

Mark Saullo sold 152 Burr Place, Jamestown to Atticus at Chautauqua, LLC of Westerville, Ohio for $33,000.

Anthony J.R. Genco and Anthony J. Genco sold 102 East Main St., Falconer to Mission Hearing, LLC of Jamestown for $145,000.

A referee for Dennis Walrod sold 4622 Cowing Road, Busti to Adolph Morano for $145,000. Morano then sold a different parcel with that same address to Karen Ohl for $21,735.

Keith and Sherry Prittie sold 5446 Weaver Road, Ellery to Edward and Shirley Vanord for $70,200.

Jacob Michaud sold 24 Woodworth Ave., Jamestown to Mark and Marki Tauzel for $84,900.

David Leuzzi and Tia Leuzzi sold 14 Westerly Drive, Fredonia to David Leuzzi for $21,570.

George Wheeler and Patrick Wheeler sold 279 Lake Shore Drive West, Dunkirk to Nas Capital Development, LLC of Dunkirk for $179,000.

Allegany-Erie Inc. of Dunkirk sold 199 W. Point Ave., Dunkirk to Nas Capital Development, LLC for $1,000.

Kenneth Long II sold 129 Frazier St., Dunkirk to David and Joanne Perez for $181,000.

HBS CTQ, LLC of Pittsburgh, Pa. sold 4365 Lakeside Drive, Ellery to Rollin III and Kimberly Reading for $1,850,000.

Errol McNallie sold 1180 Bunce Road, Carroll to Rebecca Carlson for $70,000.

James and Linda Kosthorst sold 235 Indiana Ave., Jamestown to Steven and Sharon Carlson for $159,900.

Catina Barbalato sold 73 E. Seventh St., Dunkirk to Aimee Thompson for $100,000.

Thomas Schwarz and Mary Lepley sold property on West Cobb Road, Poland to Matthew Howard and Taylor Ross for $45,000.

MRR Property Solutions, LLC of West Seneca sold 106 Weeks St., Jamestown to Jorhan Guerrero Castillo for $9,900.

Chautauqua Inns, LTD of Mayville sold property on Jefferson and North Portage streets, Westfield to Mazza Chautauqua Cellars, LLC of North East, Pa. for $90,000.

Cynthia Testrake-Seblink sold 83 Union St., Westfield to Demitri Shakhray and Natalie Ball-Shakhray for $189,000.

George Wamsley sold 125 Hamlet St., Fredonia to Keely Geise Burlett for $144,900.

Press Holdings, LLC of Forestville sold 637 Brigham Road, Dunkirk to AE&G Services, LLC of Fleming Island, Fla. for $125,000.

The Administrator of the Estate of Michael Gullotti sold a parcel on Kiantone Road, Kiantone to Jay and Jaime Lauffenburger for $28,000.

Brenda Kelly sold 510 Weeks St., Jamestown to Dakota and Alyssa Nadolny for $122,000.

Paul and Arie Troyer sold property on Clymer Sherman Road, Clymer to Albert and Lena Troyer for $25,000.

Paul Mattis and Natalie Gelbke-Mattis sold 7086 Nelson Road, Charlotte to Jodi Hadley for $335,000.

A referee for Gary Kennelley sold 10 Price St., Jamestown to Freddie Mac Seasoned Credit Risk Transfer Trust for $42,000.

Benedetto Enterprises, Inc. of Jamestown sold a parcel on Wilson Avenue, Jamestown to Madison and Michelle Tanner for $115,000.

The Administrator of the Estate of Kevin Carlson sold 23 ½ Water St., Carroll to Jessica Moll, Megan Moll, Dominick Bartell-Servey, and Donovan Pulliam for $39,900.

Mark Warner, Lori Kooken and Amy Benton sold 5337 Ply Hill Road, North Harmony to Jacob and Kelly Picchione for $275,000.

John Tourjie sold 9213 Round Top Road, Villenova to Round Top Partners, LLC of Angola for $185,000.

The Chautauqua County Land Bank Corporation sold 172 S. Margay St., Dunkirk to Audrey Reading for $12,500.

Tammy Ross sold 6241 Rt. 20, Portland to SP&Z Corporation for $65,000.

Steven Phillips sold 13 Merz Ave., Bemus Point to Richard Hymer for $327,900.

Jodi Charlton sold 136 East Main St., Brocton to Jonathan Garigal for $166,000.

JULY 31

Michael Saar and Todd Carlson sold a parcel on Sherman Stedman Road, Sherman to Geoffrey Maze for $140,000.

Jose and Lisette Cabrera sold 322 East Main St., Falconer to Cynthia Lorraine Mort for $132,000.

Jeffrey Kline sold Lot 3, Block F, 2452 Sunnyside Road, Mina to David and Brenda Urban for $500.

Phuongdung Le sold 86 East Fourth St., Dunkirk to Peter Lebron for $75,000.

Jeffrey Smith and Linda DeJoseph sold 302 State St., Jamestown to William and Karen Mott for $176,500.

The executor of the Last Will and Testament of Margaret Beckman sold 1001 Edgewater Drive, Westfield to the Laura G. Stewart-Beach Revocable Trust for $160,000.

Sandra Green sold 2753 Erickson Road, North Harmony to the Todd J. and Kristina L. Rahman Real Estate Trust for $230,001.

The Administratrix of the Estate of Louis Racitano sold 520 Foote Ave., Jamestown to Patricia Cooper for $25,000.

George Simmons and Kathleen Kelly sold two parcels on Concord Drive, Pomfret to Marcus Deas for $75,000.

Jon and Melissa Hamilton sold 227 Elmcrest Ave., Lakewood to Brandon Lucariello for $208,000.

Martin and Judith Rowe sold 4 Mechanic St., Ripley to William Burch and Ann See for $95,000.

Newsletter

Today's breaking news and more in your inbox

I'm interested in (please check all that apply)
Are you a paying subscriber to the newspaper? *
   

COMMENTS

Starting at $4.62/week.

Subscribe Today