Trending
The Dunkirk Common Council advanced a law that would override a state-imposed property tax cap.
Rhetoric about the proposed 2027 city budget dominated the council meeting. Passing the tax cap law would directly affect the budget, allowing City Hall to soak Dunkirk property owners for more money. Mayor Kate Wdowiasz's proposed 2027 budget calls for an approximately 11% tax increase.
Council voted 4-1 to schedule a public hearing on the law before its next meeting on Dec. 1. Councilwoman Natalie Luczkowiak voted "no."
Prior to the tax cap hearing vote, council members offered extensive comments on the proposed law and 2027 budget. Luczkowiak went first, explaining why she would vote against the tax cap override.
"This is not a vote on whether we have financial problems -- we do. This is a vote on whether we have earned the right to ask taxpayers to pay more than the state allows -- we have not," she said.
Luczkowiak noted the gigantic 86% tax increase from two years ago. "That was sold to the public as a fix. It was supposed to stabilize our finances -- it did not."
She said the override option "is meant to be a last resort after a municipality has cut spending, used reserves, shared services, and proven it has no other choice. The council has not been shown that work."
Instead, "What we are being asked to do is use a permanent tax increase to pay for ongoing structural deficits."
Luczkowiak added, "Once we raise the levy to this new levy, it becomes the base for next year’s cap -- we'll never get it down again. This increase will fall hardest on the people who can least afford it... For many of them, this is not an inconvenience, it's the difference between staying in their home and leaving Dunkirk."
If Dunkirk overrides its tax cap again after the 86% increase, "we are proving to the state that we cannot exercise fiscal discipline on our own, and we will invite the very control board we say we want to avoid."
Luczkowiak concluded, "I demand clean books, a real three-year plan, and real cuts before we come to taxpayers for one more dollar."
Councilman Frank Torain expressed concern that City Hall filled a position without consulting council. "We're not in a good position now, and we're looking in every place we can to see if we can bring that budget down to a reasonable state," he said.
Torain supported advancing the local law because "we should get some kind of feedback from the state" and Dunkirk should get as much feedback on its financial situation as possible. It would also permit the city to have a public hearing so residents’ voices can be heard.
"I hope going forward, we can figure out a way to fix the city’s financial issues without relying on tax increases to do it," said Councilman Gary Frederickson. "There's a lot of anger, a lot of negative feedback from people in the Third Ward about the 11% tax increase. They feel like they're being punished for living in Dunkirk. That's really not fair to them."
Councilman-at-large Nick Weiser had plenty to say, too, seeking to explain the budget process.
"Council has now completed its public departmental budget review sessions, during which we had the opportunity to work through the proposed budget in detail, hear from department heads, and examine the city's anticipated expenditures and revenues," he said. "We've also held the formal public budget hearing required by the city charter. Throughout the process, council members have been actively communicating with one another identifying potential amendments and areas for savings, and meeting with representatives of the Office of the State Comptroller (OSC) to discuss the mayor’s proposed budget. Our objective has been and continues to be to explore every reasonable avenue to maximize revenues, reduce expenditures, and lessen the tax burden to city residents whenever possible."
Weiser said OSC's budget review is anticipated by Friday. Under the state’s Fiscal Recovery Act, he said council must review that review and make recommendations consistent with the budget.
"I want to be clear: Advancing a local law to a public hearing is not a decision to exceed the property tax cap, nor does passing the local law require council to do so," Weiser continued. "It simply preserves the legal option that may become necessary, depending on the (state) comptroller’s findings and the final budget calculations."
He later added, "It is not a commitment to raise taxes beyond the cap, and it certainly does not diminish our efforts to find savings and reduce the burden on taxpayers."