Trending
Chautauqua County is now represented in a lawsuit challenging the state’s “Local Cops, Local Crimes Act.”
The law bans state law enforcement agencies from entering or maintaining 287(g) agreements with ICE, which can deputize local law enforcement to make immigration-related arrests. Initially, 15 New York sheriffs signed onto the suit. On Thursday, Chautauqua County Sheriff Jim Quattrone was added to the list along with Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman, who recently lost in his attempt to unseat Gov. Kathy Hochul, and the Nassau County sheriff and police commissioner.
"The proposed amendments could not have been made earlier," attorney Mateo Forero-Norena of the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) in his memorandum of law supporting adding the new plaintiffs, including Quattrone. "The capacity allegations are being added in light of the concerns articulated in the court's Nov. 4 order. Meanwhile, adding Sheriff Quattrone and the Nassau County parties required completing the necessary arrangements with undersigned counsel and assembling supporting materials after the original complaint was filed. Plaintiffs elected not to seek to add them while the preliminary injunction briefing was underway so as not to complicate that emergency proceeding. This motion is being filed promptly after the Nov. 4 order and before defendants' response to the complaint is due. No discovery has occurred, and the case remains at the pleading stage. Defendants do not contend that the timing of this motion constitutes undue delay. They have taken no position on the proposed amendments."
Under the 287(g) program led by Immigration and Customs Enforcement, police officers can interrogate immigrants in their custody and detain them for potential deportation.Since President Donald Trump took office in January 2025, ICE had expanded the number of signed agreements it has with law enforcement agencies across the country. That prompted Democrats in the state Legislature, with support from Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James, to enact the Local Cops, Local Crimes Act. Hochul and James have defended the law as a way to protect public safety. The state has since taken legal action against Rensselaer County, the lead plaintiff in the suit, to force compliance with the new law.
Prior to 2025, only one of New York’s 62 counties had a 287(g) agreement with ICE. As of July, there were 12 local law enforcement agencies with 287(g) contracts with ICE. In July James sent letters to the 12 local law enforcement agencies in New York that had 287(g) agreements with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), informing them that state law requires they unwind the agreements by August 25, 2026.
"Here in New York, we need local police focused on keeping our communities safe--not serving as de-facto ICE agents, not conducting civil immigration enforcement, and not carrying out the Trump Administration's callous immigration agenda," Hochul said in July. "That's why I championed our new law banning 287(g) agreements and ensuring local cops remain focused on real crime in our communities. Starting today, ICE can no longer commandeer locally-funded police to aid an out-of-control federal agency with an $85 billion budget."
The federal lawsuit to which Quattrone is now attached asks the U.S. District Court to declare that the Local Crimes, Local Cops Act is unconstitutional under the Contracts Clause of the U.S. Constitution, the 10th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution as well as under multiple sections of the New York State Constitution. FAIR is also asking the court to find that the state’s Executive Law Section 63-E, as applied to the sheriffs and counties, is unconstitutional under both the state and federal constitutions. Attorneys are also asking for an injunction keeping the state from enforcing the Local Crimes, Local Cops Act.
The lawsuit argues that New York is tearing up valid contracts the sheriffs already signed with the federal government, coercing independent elected officials into a statewide policy of non-cooperation, and overriding the constitutional authority of the Office of Sheriff. Several of the plaintiff sheriffs maintain long-standing 287(g) agreements and federal housing contracts that let them identify and transfer criminal aliens already in their jails. Albany has now declared those agreements illegal, set hard deadlines to kill them, and created a new investigative office to police any sheriff who refuses to comply.
"New York's law does not merely decline to cooperate with immigration enforcement priorities. It actively dismantles existing, congressionally authorized partnerships that sheriffs lawfully entered to protect their communities," said Dale L. Wilcox, executive director and general counsel of FAIR, when the lawsuit was filed in August. "Independently elected sheriffs should not be forced by Albany to abandon tools that keep dangerous criminal aliens from walking back onto their streets. This lawsuit seeks to restore the status quo and vindicate the independence of the Office of Sheriff."