Breaking News
Commentary

Ninety percent is not diversity of thought

4 min read

From previous years, you, faithful reader of this column, know what has happened. An organization legally separate from Chautauqua Institution and headquartered outside of the institution annually invites a speaker to the institution. More than 90 percent of the speakers over the years have been liberals.

Guess what? That's right. The organization invited another liberal in 2026.

* * *

Please don't misunderstand: The organization has every right to be as liberal as it wants to be. At its Chautauqua events, it has no obligation ever to give a non-liberal the time of day, much less invite a non-liberal to stand on its podium or behind its lectern.

You've read here about the organization's Chautauqua speakers in recent years.

The 2023 speaker disagreed with the Supreme Court's holding that race-based college and university admissions violate the Fourteenth Amendment's Equal Protection Clause.

The 2024 speaker--whom Chautauqua Institution has invited to give a morning-amphitheater lecture in 2027--described non-liberal high-court results with words such as "madness," "hubris," "a lack of humility," "wildly disruptive," "outlandish," and "audacious."

The 2025 speaker said a 2000 high-court opinion was "the first time really that the Supreme Court made a decision that was just impossible to justify on the basis of its pre-existing law." Thus, the speaker believes (1) Dred Scott v. Sandford, the 1857 decision creating a right to own slaves where no such right had existed, and (2) Plessy v. Ferguson, the 1896 decision upholding racially-segregated public accommodations, were possible for the Supreme Court "to justify on the basis of its pre-existing law."

Then came 2026, when the speaker was a veteran of two investigations of President Trump 45. Although that doesn't reveal the speaker's perspective, those hoping for diversity of thought could have suspected they were in for disappointment when the speaker prefaced thoughts on three topics with this: "It's well to remember the Supreme Court's potential for fallibility and the chance for correction at times like these when the court's decisions can engender intense controversy."

The words "at times like these" and "controversy"--even disregarding the word "intense"--all but tipped the speaker's hand.

The three topics were three Supreme Court decisions from the October 2025 to June 2026 term. The speaker advocated (1) birthright citizenship, (2) drawing congressional-district lines based partly on race, and (3) letting boys--meaning children with XY chromosomes--play on girls' sports teams.

● As for birthright citizenship, the speaker liked the court's opinion and added this: "The court's decision can be viewed as a judicial statue of liberty, a welcoming beacon to those born on our shores. … But the clarity of those sources could not erase a dark undercurrent in American thought: Resistance to sharing the blessings of citizenship to those people who are outside the mainstream. This was a thought that never truly faded from national discourse."

Let's set aside possible haughtiness in "a dark undercurrent" and consider this: Whatever the speaker means by "dark," please imagine the uproar if the speaker's opponents used the word "dark" to describe the speaker's position.

● As for race-based congressional-district lines, the speaker introduced the topic with this: "The Voting Rights Act gives equal opportunity to members of a racial group to elect representatives of their choice."

But that begged a question: One issue before the court was whether the Voting Rights Act guarantees election results or the right to vote.

● As for boys playing on girls' sports teams, the speaker said this is about "the rights of citizens to be treated as individuals by their state."

No, it's about fairness to girls.

* * *

Yet whether the organizations' speakers are right or wrong is not--not--the point here.

Having speakers stand on the podium and behind the lectern, and advocate such positions, is fine.

The point is that more than 90 percent of the organization's speakers have toed the liberal line.

Indeed, it has been many years since the organization invited someone who wasn't a toe-the-line liberal. The lack of balance in the organization's Chautauqua programs makes it easy to predict the general direction of what any speaker whom the organization invites to Chautauqua would say on any given jurisprudential topic.

Ninety percent is not diversity of thought.

* * *

Dr. Randy Elf's Aug. 20, 2020, Advocates for Balance at Chautauqua presentation, on "How Political Speech Law Benefits Politicians and the Rich," is at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3ebymA7xOo. For more on the sports-teams issue, please see the interview of him at 0:11.00 to 0:15.00 of https://accesschautauquacountytv.org/episode/GVbIPKfKKmw.

COPYRIGHT © 2026 BY RANDY ELF

Starting at /week.