Trending
Anyone paying attention to state and federal politics has heard the word socialist ad nauseam ever since the 2024 elections. While on the campaign trail, President Donald Trump called Kamala Harris a socialist at every stop. Trump continues to call his political opponents socialists. During the 2026 election cycle, many Republican candidates have called their Democratic opponents socialists. In recent primaries, even Democrats have called fellow Democrats socialists and cautioned primary voters to beware.
As the phrase continues to be thrown around politically it may be helpful for individuals to examine the meaning of the word and to look at the platforms of politicians and the statements that they make to see if the candidates really are socialists. Understanding the meaning of the term may also help individuals determine if there is more to the word than just being a slur or an insult for a political opponent.
Socialism is defined as an economic and political system where the means of production — such as factories, land, machinery and natural resources — are owned or controlled collectively by the public, the community, or the state. A core characteristic of socialism is production for use where the economic focus is placed on meeting human needs such as food, housing, healthcare and education rather than generating private profit. There are different types and variations of socialism. While the United States operates fundamentally as a capitalist mixed economy, the government is filled with socialist programs that citizens make use of and benefit from every day.
Some examples of socialist programs in the U.S. government include public education, fire and police services, and our public works and infrastructure system. The roads that we drive on every day, the mail that we receive and the water and sewer systems that we use are all provided by socialism. Targeted safety net programs like Medicaid, Medicare, SNAP, Section 8 Housing and Social Security all operate under a model of collective security rather than private profit. While the U.S. military is not considered a completely socialist system, the U.S. military does operate using distinctly socialized principles. These socialist elements include state funding and ownership, universal socialized benefits for service members and their families and the lack of a free market profit motive. The U.S government doesn't profit off of our military. Defense contractors do.
In a similar fashion, the state and federal prison systems also operate under socialist principles.
It seems rather silly for one party or one politician to call another socialist when every elected official in our country is in favor of some form of socialism. I have viewed a number of town hall meetings, rallies, debates and interviews with both Democrat and Republican candidates.
A prominent candidate being labeled as a socialist sums up his platform pillars in three sentences. Money out of politics. Money in your pockets. Healthcare for all. When Trump descended the golden escalator in Trump Towers and announced his candidacy for president more than a decade ago, he promised to drain the swamp. He promised to cut taxes and Trump promised to repeal the Affordable Care Act and replace it with a bigger and better health care program that would cover the entire country. Sounds like Trump promised to get money out of politics, put money in your pockets and provide health care for all. Why is it that when Trump says this he's putting America First and Making America Great Again but when the other guy says it, he's a socialist?
President Trump has put into place several economic interventions that have been labeled by economists as venture socialism. The Trump administration has acquired or demanded direct minority ownership shares in private corporations in exchange for federal grants, subsidies or contracts. The U.S. government now has equity stakes or part ownership in companies including Intel, MP Materials, Lithium America Global Foundries and Kepler. Other socialist interventions undertaken by the Trump administration include the demand for managerial control rights and veto power on corporate transactions, revenue sharing demands, pharmaceutical price controls and agricultural subsidies and direct payouts to farmers. I am not saying that any of these interventions are good or bad. Readers can decide that fo themselves. But these interventions are definitely socialistic in nature. While Trump warns against Democratic Socialism, is the President actually a Republican Socialist?
I think that it's safe to say that in some way, shape or form all Americans are socialists. Our country could not function without some forms of socialism. It is just a question of what types and how much socialism you are in favor of. Forget the negative connotation attached to the word and determine what kind of socialist you are. And just as importantly, what type of socialist that you are going to vote for?
Andrew Ludwig is a retired math teacher and a retired public school and Catholic school administrator. He currently works as a substitute teacher in Chautauqua County.