Richard Makuch has once again complained about a non-Dunkirk resident remarking on his “critical remarks,” that are “false,” and that apologies are owed to him and Dunkirk residents.

For years he has argued against non-Dunkirk residents having anything to say about situations located in Dunkirk. Examples are the NRG Power Plant issue, the library vote, Brooks Hospital and the proposed methadone clinic. He apparently believes we are not entitled or eligible to speak on such regionwide issues. He seems to fail to understand that these are regional issues and their impact and importance extend far beyond the city limits, necessitating our input.

As to the Fredonia woman’s husband working in City Hall, there do not appear to be residency requirements to do so, nor restrictions on freedom of expression. As for relocation of Brooks Hospital, the Fredonia Planning Board made the right decision. To have just remained silent while a location was being sought, would have been irresponsible to the entire region.

In the Nov. 29, 2019 OBSERVER, Publisher John D’Agostino reported on the progress of local communities to grow. It clearly points out the need for regionalism, building relationships in government and community members, sharing services, consolidation, and most importantly, the benefits of doing so, for one and all. (Merging of school districts belongs in the same discussion).

Mr. Makuch, on the other hand, seems to be advocating for just the opposite, i.e. isolationism, simply the wrong idea if he wants Dunkirk to grow as he previously expressed re: the “downtown business district.” Perhaps a reading of John Donne’s poem, “No Man is an Island,” will help understand the issue.

As for an apology, there is no reason to do so. My belief that his allegations about “illegals” is without merit, specious and vituperative, stands and needs no apology. His use of the term “you people” was and is an unconscionable use of a demeaning term and speaks for itself, regardless of his “great relations with all nationalities.”

As we enter the holidays of giving thanks for all our blessings, I am struck by the contrast between a time of peace on earth and goodwill to all, versus the degree of anger, angst, and general dissatisfaction expressed in so many of the commentaries Mr. Makuch and others have written and spoken.

It is my hope that the age-old feelings of peace, calm and gentleness can once again become a bigger part in all our lives.

David E. Kowaleski Sr. is a Portland resident.