Crappie fishing fun returns to Chautauqua Lake

Cecilia and Mike Shore from North Carolina enjoyed their springtime fishing for Chautauqua Lake crappie near Long Point Marina earlier this week. Photo courtesy of Fishing with Dad LLC
As winter loosens its grip and the waters of Chautauqua Lake climb into the welcoming range of the 50s, something special begins to stir beneath the surface.
For anglers, this is more than just a seasonal shift — it’s a reawakening.
Springtime crappie fishing here has a way of refreshing our spirit, shaking off the cold months and replacing them with anticipation, action and a sense of connection to the exciting outdoors.
Both white and black crappies are now moving into shallow zones, becoming more active and accessible by the day. The beauty of this fishery lies not just in its productivity, but in its simplicity. According to Major Stearns of Fishing with Dad Charters, success doesn’t require complicated setups or elaborate strategies.
“We keep it straightforward,” Stearns said. “A fixed float above a small 1/32 ounce jig head tipped with a minnow or a soft plastic is all you need. Then it’s about covering water — moving until you find active fish.”

When Chautauqua Lake begins to warm up in spring, the crappies move to become active and spawn. Shaun Gleason, left, and Josh Bova, both from Olean, enjoyed every second on the water. Photo courtesy of Fishing with Dad LLC
That willingness to explore is key.
“Some days might involve relocating 10 or even 12 times,” Stearns said, “but the reward is worth the effort.”
With decades of experience on the lake, Stearns has developed a deep understanding of seasonal patterns and productive locations from fishing with his dad. His approach reflects a broader truth about spring fishing here: the fish are plentiful, but finding the most active schools turns a good outing into a great one.
“One of the most exciting aspects of early-season fishing on Chautauqua Lake is how quickly conditions evolve, you need to keep up with the changes,” Stearns said.
The southern basin warms faster than the north, drawing fish and anglers into productive areas like Ashville Bay and Burtis Bay. These sheltered waters become hotspots of activity depending on water temperature changes and wind direction, but when conditions are just right, the crappies gather in impressive numbers. It’s not uncommon to see kayakers quietly working these zones, casting into promising pockets and enjoying the calm, immersive experience that only spring fishing can offer.
Right now, it’s not just crappies making waves. Yellow perch have recently completed their spawn, signaling another important seasonal milestone. Meanwhile, anglers are reporting catch-and-release encounters with largemouth bass, hinting at even more opportunities as the season progresses. The lake feels alive — dynamic, diverse, and ready to reward those who venture out.
Access remains convenient for eager anglers. Currently, Long Point Marina serves as the primary launch point while restoration work continues (nearly complete) at the Bemus Point Boat Launch. Those improvements will further enhance access to one of the region’s most beloved fisheries.
For those new to crappie fishing — or simply looking to sharpen their skills — this is an ideal time to consider hiring a guide. Time on the water with an experienced professional like Captain Stearns can accelerate the learning curve, offering insights into presentation, location and seasonal behavior that might otherwise take years to develop. It’s not just about catching fish; it’s about understanding them. Trips booked through May 1 are affordable at $300 for two anglers for a four-hour trip, all gear provided, with a $100 fee per additional anglers. Contact Stearns at 716-758-1379, or visit “Fishing with Dad” on Facebook.
Perhaps the greatest appeal of spring fishing on Chautauqua Lake is its accessibility. Whether you’re casting from a boat, drifting in a kayak, fishing in the Ashville Marina Canals, or learning the ropes with a guide — the experience is welcoming and rewarding. It’s a fishery that offers something for everyone from seasoned anglers chasing a limit to newcomers seeking their first bite of the year.
In the end, this is more than a fishing trip. It’s an invitation to step outside, to explore, and to rediscover the simple thrill of a tug on the line. As the lake warms and the crappies bite, there’s no better time to get out and be part of it.
Gotta love the outdoors.
CALENDAR
April 17-19: NYS Conservation Council Meeting, Register at https://www.nyscc.com/spring-mtg-2026. Cost: $35.
April 18: Southtowns Walleye Association Sportsman Raffle event, noon-4 p.m., free refreshments with entry tick ($25), Info: Jim Stechenfinger, 716-310-4646.
April 18: Niagara Musky Association, Awards Banquet, Eldredge Club, 17 Broad St., Tonawanda, 6-10 p.m., $35, Ticket info: Scott McKee, 716-225-3816.
April 18-19: NYS Pistol Permit Class, 9:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., Northern Chautauqua Conservation Club, fee: $250. NRA Certified Instructor: Gary H. Dudek. Info: 716-366-3397.
April 19: Westfield Fish and Game Club, Spring Shoot, 11 a.m., open to the public, 8150 Ogden Road, Westfield, 716-326-2289.
ııı
Submit calendar items to forrestfisher35@yahoo.com at least 10 days in advance.
- Cecilia and Mike Shore from North Carolina enjoyed their springtime fishing for Chautauqua Lake crappie near Long Point Marina earlier this week. Photo courtesy of Fishing with Dad LLC
- When Chautauqua Lake begins to warm up in spring, the crappies move to become active and spawn. Shaun Gleason, left, and Josh Bova, both from Olean, enjoyed every second on the water. Photo courtesy of Fishing with Dad LLC






